Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Plywood vs MDF

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Plywood vs MDF

    I've seen many post they cut puzzles from plywood. Has anyone ever used MDF with a veneer instead? Any significant differences between these two I should be aware of?
    Sawdust King

    If there is one thing I can make perfect every time it is sawdust.

  • #2
    Just my opinions but...

    DUST - Cutting MDF produces an incredibly fine dust that is difficult to collect.
    MOISTURE - MDF likes to absorb moisture and swell so I'm not sure it is suitable for use when you are making locking pieces for puzzles.
    EDGE - I find that MDF has a tendency to edge chip much more easily than plywood.

    george
    A day without sawdust is a day without sunshine.
    George

    delta 650, hawk G426

    Comment


    • #3
      I agree with George on his points. MDF breaks rather easily and I would be afraid any mishandling would break off the interlocking tabs, creating a choking hazard...
      "Still Montana Mike"

      "Don't worry about old age--it doesn't last that long."
      Mike's Wood-n-Things LLC

      Comment


      • #4
        Thanks. I had seen MDF where I can get Baltic Birch and with the different veneers and appearance of a solid core was wondering if it would be a viable alternative to plywood. I'll take it as a no and stick with the plywoods.

        Thanks again.
        Sawdust King

        If there is one thing I can make perfect every time it is sawdust.

        Comment


        • #5
          Hi

          I make lots of things with MDF and do not find it a problem all, especially when you are paiting it. I use a vacuum cleaner attached to my saw, the dust does not create much mess (I wear a mask for cutting everything). I have never had a problem with it breaking, I often have pieces break out of ply. As for swelling, I think you would have to immerse it in water and ply would't stand up to that either. I have not used veneered MDF. Go for it, I would if I had some local availability.

          Sue

          Comment


          • #6
            I did the Tiger Butterfly a few years ago and used MDF for the backing. I ended up painting the MDF and in my opinion I liked it better than the plywood and I am not a good painter. No chips, No swelling I may have been lucky.

            Comment


            • #7
              This was discussed a month ago and people pointed out that MDF has formaldehyde in it. HDF / hardyboard does not however. I found HDF at Home Depot and/or Lowes but can't recall what it was called...hard board or some such thing. I did not buy any - only came in 4x8 sheets and decided to use plywood. I like the idea of MDF/HDF (for adults) though since people are used to that type of material for puzzles, and it should be flat - not warped like plywood.

              Comment

              Unconfigured Ad Widget

              Collapse

              Latest Topics

              Collapse

              • will8989
                Reply to Source for 5-Ply poplar plywood?
                by will8989
                I do all my puzzles in 3/4” wood, mostly poplar but some cherry or walnut....
                Yesterday, 10:57 PM
              • millwab
                Reply to Source for 5-Ply poplar plywood?
                by millwab
                Understandable for your baskets Betty, but in my experience 1/4” solid wood for puzzles tends to not hold up very well. Especially the small locks....
                Yesterday, 08:57 AM
              • will8989
                Planer do
                by will8989
                Should read planer Died yesterday. But Bruce got out his instruction book and google and got it apart. Needs new belt, plastic cover and pulley gear. Ordered from eBay and should have by Monday. Of course all work on dough boards stopped. $55 is much cheaper than a new planer. Oh well, on to the next...
                Yesterday, 08:48 AM
              • will8989
                Reply to Source for 5-Ply poplar plywood?
                by will8989
                My customers won’t buy anything cut from plywood. I’ve spoiled them. I use poplar for all my kid puzzles. With Bruce volunteering at the County Park antique sawmill, I have an endless supply of poplar. My current batch is green and white striped. I make cases for all my puzzles and back them with...
                Yesterday, 08:43 AM
              • will8989
                Reply to Wood supply
                by will8989
                I have enough of that. I bought 3 sheets of 1/8 and 1/4 a few months back. Bruce was at the sawmill yesterday and the superintendent of the Park told them they were getting over 50 oak trees from various county parks. The trees have sort of bug that is killing them . They will be quarantining them in...
                Yesterday, 07:40 AM
              Working...
              X