Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

    Hello! I am the newest member ronbar; Ron Barras, Houston, Texas! I hand build small clocks, small furniture pieces and casework. I have decided in starting a website and that I need a good scroll saw for this type of work. I do not think it is reasonable to 'invest' right off the bat in an RBI, Hegner or Excalibur. So I am looking at either the DeWalt (made by Sommerville) or the new Delta SS350 (previously Delta 40-570). I would like to know anyones suggestions. The Delta has an outlet for a dust collector. It is also heavy for less vibration I would think. Also, it has a table insert, for user made zero clearance inserts I guess. The DeWalt seems like a good saw also. It does not have a dust collection outlet though. I would appreciate anyone's help and preferences as to these two saws.  Thanks!

  • #2
    Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

    I own a DeWalt scroll saw and have had zero problems with it. I bolted it down to my workbench and it has very little vibration. It is actually pretty heavy, too. I also use it to cut out pieces for carving, especially pieces for clocks. I think you could rig up a dust collector using a box fan, a furnace filter and some thin plywood. BTW, the DeWalt uses the same type of mechanism as the Excaliber and that reduces the vibration. The Delta uses a conventional mechanism that tends to have more vibration and the weight is there as a way to minimize it.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

      Hello I have the the Dewalt scrollsaw and would buy it again.
      I have had this one for three years and use it weekly.
      I cut puzzles out of 1 1/2 inch pine and have used it on oak.
      It should have insert on it. ???
      Check pricing on it before you buy, I found it for 399 at Menards store in Sterling IL , and 459 at a Menards in Freeport IL. Good Luck
      Mick

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

        Just like carving tools - buy the best you can afford - I bought an inexpensive Ryobi when I started and lived with it for about a year before breaking down and buy and rbi hawk - it was like dying and going to heaven - absolutely no comparison - don't know about the dewalt, but they're a good company with a good reputation and other seem to like them so should be o.k.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

          I have bought and used Craftman schroll sawes for many years and decided to look for a better saw as Craftman's are not frett work friendly. I have lok at the Excaliber and others and decided to Buy a RBI Hawk 216 as several friends have them and they enjoy working with them. Have used their Hawk 216 and 226 several times to see if I would want one.
          Most of my o\projects are not as big to use the Hawk 226 so I am was leaning to the Hawk 216. BUT RBI had a sale of the Hawk 220 and bought it. Yes It is like being in heaven. Enjoying it more and have less problems with chattering and blade breakage.
          Thanks,
          Ken

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

            I got my wife a RBI Hawk about five years ago and it is still running like a new one.... she loves it ..... but, she won't let me use it !! When I bought it they took my old Sears scroll saw in trade and gave me the the price I had paid for the Sears saw new. !! Can't beat that !

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

              Hi Ronbar,welcome.I use a delta 40-540c scrollsaw that I purchased 3 years ago for less than 200.00{Cdn.}I use it for everything and for just about every imaginable kind of wood.I have never had any problems with i,and I use it for 4-5 hours a day.The only thing I dont like about it is the blower system,but I corrected that by hooking up an aquarium aeriater to it.Works great.I am thinking of upgrading to an Excalber as it has a deeper working area,but that is down the road abit.Hope I helped abit.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

                If you are still wondering, get the RBI. I have 2 of them. There just is none better.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

                  I have had a Sears 20' Contractor model scrollsaw for about 8 years. I love it! I own a Ryobi, but never use it--it stinks---very bad vibration and it just doesn't have the capabilities I need. Never tried the Dewalt.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Which Scroll Saw to Buy?

                    I have a Delta scroll saw with a 16' cutting throat and variable speed. it works quite well, i have no complaints but I would Prefer to buy a DeWalt because there's less vibration. There were problems with the motors burning out on the DeWalts as I remember when i was looking at a new saw. Also, you can cut larger pieces with the DeWalt.

                    Comment

                    Unconfigured Ad Widget

                    Collapse

                    Latest Topics

                    Collapse

                    • Linda In Phoenix
                      Reply to YoraHome Laser w/CNC Engraver/Router
                      by Linda In Phoenix
                      New toys sometimes become tools we can use, and other times they simply are tools toward expanding our horizons and being there when an idea pops into our heads. Let us know what you try the Ortur on and how it does. I'm sincerely curious. Also....why did you choose Amazon vs the other vendors...
                      Yesterday, 11:47 PM
                    • will8989
                      What is it?
                      by will8989
                      Bruce was bored and made this. What is it?...
                      Yesterday, 10:57 PM
                    • will8989
                      Reply to First you need to make a mess
                      by will8989
                      It was a challenge that’s for sure. I didn’t start anything until I was all finished. It’s nice to have a clean area to work in! My biggest challenge was all those pieces of scrap wood that I just might need “someday.” They burned well in my son’s woodstove. And I did get through all the patterns....
                      Yesterday, 10:54 PM
                    • tgiro01
                      Reply to First you need to make a mess
                      by tgiro01
                      Wow - Betty, what do you charge. I have things to do and I'm in the process of cleaning my shop, just to have room to do it. My problem is that I get the work bench cleared and then start working on projects again. I really need to do the workbench last.
                      Yesterday, 10:05 PM
                    • tgiro01
                      Reply to YoraHome Laser w/CNC Engraver/Router
                      by tgiro01
                      I ordered and received the ORTUR Laser Master 2 from Amazon, the but haven't had a chance to even get it out of the box. Too much going
                      on right now. I got the 20 watt version, which is supposed to be good for cutting, but I don't think I'll be doing much of that. There will be a learning curve...
                      Yesterday, 09:57 PM
                    Working...
                    X