No announcement yet.

Everyone Makes Mistakes

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Everyone Makes Mistakes

    I was recently cutting a layered project. 5 layers deep cut from resawn wood.
    The grain patterns flowed smoothly through all pieces.
    There are a few lines that need to be the same on all pieces so I stack cut the first few cuts.
    I then cut the back layer first, then the next and so on.
    As I came to glue the pattern on the second to last piece I noticed that my initial cut had removed some of the wood I needed to complete the project.

    So I have some options left.
    1. I can discard the entire project
    2. I can place a similar piece of wood in the sandwiched frame to complete the project
    3. I can leave it the way it is and keep it around as a sad reminder
    4. i can set fire to my shop and collect the insurance

    Just kidding with the last remark.
    I am asking scrollers, when, if any time , is it OK to repair, or patch a project?
    This project is one of four identical projects I have been commissioned to do.

    It is not the end of the world if I have to start over. I had fun cutting it the first time I am sure I will have fun cutting it again
    "proud member of the best scroll sawing forum on the net."
    Ryobi SC180VS scroll saw EX21

  • #2
    Carl, I would say it is okay to patch or repair if it won't be noticable. I don't do commison work but I have broken pieces off of portraits and scenic pictures I have done and just glued them back on. I know where they are but others can't tell. Mick.
    Mick, - Delta P-20

    A smile is a small curve that straightens everything out.


    • #3
      "The superior man understands what is right; the inferior man understands what will sell." --Confucius


      • #4
        I had already decided what to do with this particular project, I am just curious what others would do.
        That Confucius guy never seems to post much these days. I wonder if he is spending too much time at his saw?

        I really should have included more details before I posted because each project we do is different.
        My material cost was zero, I designed the pattern and printed it off so that cost was negligible and here is the kicker, I maybe spent an hour cutting time on the project.

        No one but me would ever know there was an error, but boy does it erk me that I am to blame
        "proud member of the best scroll sawing forum on the net."
        Ryobi SC180VS scroll saw EX21


        • #5

          Attached is a photo of a mistake I tried to correct. I cut the geese in a slab of basswood and the piece didn't look I stained it. Then it REALLY didn't look right!!! I was going to pitch it but decided to experiment. I retrieved a few tubes of acrylic from my duck carving days and this is the result. A did a quick paint job therefore it still doesn't look very good but a whole new realm of creativity has opened up. Just goes to show that one can hide a lot of sin with a coat of paint!!!
          Attached Files
          If it don't fit, don't force it....get a bigger hammer!!


          • #6
            Geez! Of course it is permissible to correct a mistake. Gary Browning says in one of his books that "that is the reason they invented glue." I think he is correct. When you start (if you haven't already) doing projects, like some of Jeff Zaffino's patterns, with a large number of very fine lines and internal cuts, you can't help but "mess up" sometime. Most folks won't even know you made a mistake. The only time I won't "fix" a mistake is when it would take more time and effort than restarting/redoing the project.
            Old Mooner


            Unconfigured Ad Widget


            Latest Topics


            • Sandy Oaks
              Teach - Learn
              by Sandy Oaks
              A modified Sue Mey pattern to fit 1" x 4" x 10" Hard Maple. Cut on the Pegas scroll saw using a Pegas #5 MGT blade. One side says "TEACH". Flip it over and the other side says "LEARN". After sanding, dipped in diluted Shellac, sanded again and another dipping. Comments...
              You do not have permission to view this gallery.
              This gallery has 2 photos.
              Today, 12:13 PM
            • Sandy Oaks
              Reply to First Project - Stretching Cat
              by Sandy Oaks
              Very well done, especially for your first. I too like the added detail.
              Today, 11:22 AM
            • Rolf
              Reply to Insertion of a marquetry pattern in a stained glass window
              by Rolf
              The end result is beautiful I really like that Hummingbird design....
              Today, 09:54 AM
            • Rolf
              Reply to Help with spray adhesive
              by Rolf
              I have used all sorts of methods for putting on patterns. The only time I put a pattern directly on the wood is on Intarsia as the shaping process removes it. I only use blue tape under the pattern on very small projects.

              I Use clear removable contact paper (shelf liner) on the wood and...
              Today, 09:51 AM
            • Rolf
              Reply to Sanding and calibration disk.
              by Rolf
              I agree about how it was advertised, but it is my own fault, I know better. Just for curiosity I may strip the paint off and see how true the plate is.

              The good thing is that while I had my saw blade off I cleaned it sprayed Crud cutter on it let it sit then wiped it off with a skotchbright...
              Today, 09:42 AM